Summary These are the first chapters
that shift from third person to first person. All four start with some version
of naming and claiming Beloved, such as Sethe's "Beloved, she my daughter. She
mine." Chapter 2 is first person from Sethe's point of view. She is elated to
have Beloved back in her life, and she then tells more about why she couldn't
escape with her children when they left Sweet Home. She went out to meet the
Underground Railroad in the corn, but Halle and the others weren't there. So,
Sethe went back for Halle, sending her children on ahead of her. Then the boys
held her down and nursed her milk and she told Mrs. Garner, for which they
whipped her. Now, however, she has her daughters and she feels she does not
have to explain herself because they understand her actions.
Chapter 3 is first person
from Denver's point of view. She claims Beloved for her own because she is her
sister. When Denver was a child, she went to an informal school for a little
while, until one of the other children told her what Sethe had done to her
children. Then, Denver stopped hearing and started hearing again only when the
baby's ghost started crawling up the stairs in the house. So, she claims
Beloved as hers because she was the first to recognize who the ghost was and
was also the first to recognize the reincarnated woman. Denver loves her
mother but has always been frightened that she will hurt her again, as were
Buglar and Howard, which is why they left to go fight in the war. Denver has
always been waiting for her father, who she believes is gentle, to come for
her, and she now believes that Beloved has come to wait for their father with
her.
Chapter 4 is first person
from Beloved's point of view, and Beloved is claiming Sethe as her own. The
writing style is very fragmented because she is describing the experience of
being dead. She describes men without skin, who are white men, and how
difficult it is to truly be dead. Some of the people move along into the
water, being truly dead, but she finds that hard. She talks about seeing a
woman's face that she wants when she is dead, but then the face is taken away.
So, she pulls herself up to a bridge, and when she sees Sethe's face when she
is sitting on the stump, she knows she has found the woman's face that she
wanted.
Chapter 5 is dialogue
between the three women, describing their love for and need to protect one
another. Beloved wants to protect Sethe from white men, Sethe wants to protect
Beloved from being dead, and Denver wants to protect Beloved from Sethe's
violence. They are all tightly bound together by their strong love for and
desire to possess one another.
Analysis The name "Beloved" comes
from the word on Sethe's daughter's headstone. But it also comes from the
Bible. The Song of Solomon says, "I am my Beloved's and my Beloved is mine."
This is often thought of to describe the relationship between a man and a
woman, but it actually is about the love between a human and God that can be
manifested as the love between humans. In the beginning of three chapters,
Morrison rewrites this passage, talking instead about Beloved as a character.
The dangerous and narrow love that excludes all others in this case takes a
passage that should be about the love of God and turns it into a self-absorbed
love for a person. That is dangerous, as the Song of Solomon can be read as
loving another as a part of loving God. The love between these women excludes
everyone, mortal and immortal.
However, the ability to name
Beloved "She is Beloved" is taking the power of naming away from white people
and locating it instead in the love between women. Done well, this could be
very empowering. Women naming their daughters is a part of natural familial
relationships that is taken away when people name their slaves whatever they
wish. So, these passages are about reclaiming power through love, but that can
be a very dangerous power if it excludes all others.
When Beloved describes the
experience of being on the bridge, she is not just describing the journey
between the land of the living and the land of the dead. She is also
describing the middle passage, which was when slaves were brought over from
Africa on ships. This was a difficult and dangerous journey, and it was hard
to make it to the other side. When the slaves got here, they were changed,
like Beloved is different after her journey. The middle passage is important
in many slave narratives because it was such an excruciating experience that
took civilized people and turned them into slaves. |