Head versus Heart
Hard Times shows the inadequacy of an approach to life that emphasizes only
the human intellect at the expense of the imagination and the heart. The
character who most embodies the false approach is Thomas Gradgrind.
Gradgrind worships facts and figures and prides himself on being very practical.
He thinks that the only things valuable in life are those that can be objectively
measured. He believes that human behavior can be shaped for the better by the
rational application of practical knowledge. Gradgrind refuses to accept the
validity of "fancy" or imagination; only practical things matter, and he puts his
faith in abstract theories rather than direct observation of how real people
behave, and what their real needs are. In his satirical portrait of Gradgrind,
Dickens is taking aim at what he saw as the underlying principles operating in the
industrial England of his time. It was a lop-sided approach to human life that
denied some of the basic needs of human beings.
The qualities of imagination and heart are found in the circus folk that Gradgrind
despises. Sissy Jupe in particular embodies the values of a heart-centered life. It
is for that reason that she does not thrive in Gradgrind's school. Louisa is another
victim of Gradgrind's repressive philosophy. She grows up emotionally stunted
because she has not been allowed to develop her natural qualities of heart and
imagination. The philosophy that acknowledges the value only of the intellect
leads to impoverished, inadequate lives.
Industrialism
Another of Dickens's purposes in Hard Times was to attack the conditions of life
in England's industrial cities. His fictional town of Coketown was in fact modeled
on Manchester, in northern England. Towns such as these helped to produce the
wealth that made England the foremost industrial power in the mid-nineteenth
century, but the cost in human happiness was great. In Coketown, the needs of
the factories dominate everything else. The town is an unnatural place, awash in
industrial pollution, an "ugly citadel, where Nature was as strongly bricked out as
killing airs and gases were bricked in" (Book 1, chapter 10). The factory hands
work long hours in oppressive and dangerous conditions, and they live in
cramped, unsanitary houses. Their lives are monotonous; every day is exactly
like every other day, just as all the houses and streets look alike. In Coketown,
there is a strict uniformity in everything. The workers have little time off to relax
and enjoy themselves.
Dickens also wanted to expose the bad state of relations between factory
employers and their employees. His sympathies are clearly with the workers, as
his portrait of Stephen Blackpool, the honest factory hand, shows. Dickens also
believed that employers showed little if any interest in the welfare of their
employees and often regarded them with contempt. In the novel, this kind of
employer is represented by Bounderby, who gets rich on what the factories
produce but has a low opinion of the workers, even though he does not bother to
get to know any of them at a personal level.
Although Dickens presents the problems of industrialism and industrial relations
very acutely, he does not propose any solutions. Stephen Blackpool's comment
that the bosses should simply treat their employees better, remembering that
they are real people with real feelings, strikes many critics as inadequate, given
the vastness of the industrial machine, the continual need for profits, and the
disparity in power between employers and employees. The obvious solution, that
workers should organize collectively in trade unions to protect their interests, was
not one that Dickens embraced. In Hard Times, his portrait of the trade union, led
by the fiery Slackbridge, is not an attractive one. Slackbridge himself is an
unpleasant character, and the workers are all too ready to exert a tyranny of their
own when they collectively shun Stephen Blackpool.
Education
Dickens also wanted to attack the failings of education and the
wrong-headedness of the prevailing educational philosophy. He believed that
many schools discouraged the development of the children's imaginations,
training them as "little parrots and small calculating machines" (Dickens used this
phrase in a lecture he gave in 1857). Nor did Dickens approve of the recently
instituted teacher training colleges. These had been set up in the 1840s, after the
British government acknowledged the need to raise the standard of education in
schools. The first graduates of these training colleges began teaching in 1853, a
year before the publication of Hard Times. M'Choakumchild, the teacher in
Gradgrind's school (which was a non fee-paying school that catered to the lower
classes), is Dickens's satirical portrait of one of these newly trained teachers.
Many educators at the time shared Dickens's view of what was wrong with the
schools. They believed there was too much emphasis on cramming the children
full of facts and figures, and not enough attention given to other aspects of their
development.
|