The
Englishman Gower tells the Welshman Fluellen that he is wanted by the
Duke of Gloucester at the "mines," which were tunnels dug under
besieged fortifications, so that explosives could be placed there.
Fluellen protests that the mines have not been built properly, and
anyway the French have dug counter-mines four yards under the English
ones, so they may well get blown up.
When
Fluellen learns that that it is an Irishman, Captain Macmorris, who is
in charge of the siege, he insults him, saying he is ignorant about war.
Macmorris
and the Scots Captain Jamy enter. Fluellen approves of Jamy, because he
thinks he is knowledgeable about war.
Macmorris
bemoans the fact that he has made a mess of the work he was in charge
of. Fluellen, wanting to prove how ignorant Macmorris is, tries to
engage him in a discussion about the ancient Roman wars. But Macmorris
shrugs him off, saying it is no time to talk; battle is being joined and
they must make their contributions rather than sit around talking. The
two men then quarrel after Fluellen implies that the Irish are a nation
separate from the Welsh, a suggestion that angers the Irishman.
The
quarrel is interrupted when they hear the news that the town of Harfleur
has requested to talk with the besiegers.
Henry
enters, before the gates of Harfleur, and demands to know what the
governor of the city has decided. He says that if he has to resume the
bombardment of the city again, he will reduce Harfleur to ashes and will
show no mercy to its inhabitants. He will not be able to restrain his
soldiers from rape and pillage. If this happens, it will be the fault of
the people of Harfleur, not the English. In light of this, he asks
Harfleur to submit, while he still has control of his men. Then he gives
an even more bloodthirsty picture of what will happen to man, woman and
child in Harfleur if he is denied.
The
Governor informs Henry that the Dauphin, to whom they appealed, is not
ready to come to their aid. Therefore he submits to their demands.
Henry
gives instructions to Exeter to enter the town and fortify it, and treat
the citizens well. The following day, Henry will retire with the rest of
his forces to Calais (an English possession).
Analysis
Although
Fluellen and MacMorris do quarrel, the intention of this scene is to
show that all four nations that make up the British
Isles-Scotland, Wales, Ireland and England-contribute to the war.
During the fifteenth century, England was more often in conflict with
these nations than in partnership with them, so this is an illustration
of Henry's skill in bringing rivals together for a common venture.
Henry's
speech to the governor of Harfleur is bloodcurdling in its ferocity, but
the likelihood is that Shakespeare is once more demonstrating the
King's skill at getting the outcome he wants. The mere threat of
atrocities is enough to compel the town to submit. It is notable that
when Henry does gain entrance to the city, he instructs his men to
behave in a decent fashion. Some modern readers, however, have censured
Henry because of his habit of blaming the other side for the mayhem he
is ready to commit. He does this at Harfleur, just as he had told King
Charles that he, Charles, would be to blame for the devastation that a
war would cause.
|